I'm not gonna pretend like I never refer to women as bitches or hoes. It's not right, I know it. But you'll be hard pressed to find a woman that can say that I called them a bitch or a hoe. So i'm not necessarily mad at Professor Farred for using the words black and bitch. I do find what he did to be in incredibly poor taste. I don't know the nature of his relationship with the women, maybe he thought they were cool like that, but some words are just too risky to use in jest. I had a professor at Duke that used to say "Jeremy stop acting like a little negro child" or "Jeremy why must you be such a negro child". She was just joking with me. I never felt offended by her words cuz we were cool like that. But that's me. Negro child and black bitches are two different kinda words. Considering Farred was the director of graduate studies in Africana his words carried more gravity. The DGS is pretty powerful in grad school he/she could be the difference between you graduating on time or spending another semester in school. And that is why I find issue with how the situation was handled. If the young ladies were so offended by what Farred said that they took it to the department head, Salah Hassan, Hassan should've acted quickly and quietly to discipline Farred and possibly asking for him to step down from his position as DGS. But Hassan didn't and the situation got bigger and bigger.
It's been my experience that students at Cornell are always looking for something to fight. They pounce on even the smallest things and try to make a huge deal out of it. I'm def against injustice but I also know how to pick my battles. Most folks around here don't. So when Hassan failed to take action the fire got fuel. 2 months later it's on the verge of being a negro bonfire (no KKK). Some alumni of africana wrote a letter to the president of Cornell addressing their concerns and now there's a forum tomorrow on the issue. Now I'm not saying Farred's actions weren't wrong or in poor taste, I am however, saying that all of this isn't necessary. I find forums to be mostly useless. A lot of talk and very little action. Sitting in a room and blasting Farred isn't going to change the attitudes of men towards women. That's not to say that these forums hold no value at all, I just think that at this point the issue will be directed at what Farred said and not that he thought such hurtful words could be used in jest, especially in front of the women he was referencing.
Now to the victims of Farred. He's already apologized to them for what he said. That's who he owes. But because this issues has gotten so big, I can't help but think it makes their experiences in Africana slightly uncomfortable. It'd be hard to imagine the faculty not taking sides, I just hope it doesn't adversely affect these young ladies graduate careers in the long run. I'd be curious to know if the victims ever thought/wanted the situation to get this big. It reminds me of one time a teacher said something foul to me in class. I told the person who was taking care of me at the time. She came to school and cussed the teacher flat out. Talk about embarrassing. As a result i ended up being the teacher's pet thus further alienating me from my classmates. All I really wanted was a "awww that's messed up. She shouldn't have said that" or maybe a letter sent with me to school to give the teacher. But having to watch someone get cussed out on your behalf when i really wasn't THAT big of a deal to me def sucked. I just hope that after all of this has happened it was that big of a deal to the victims, otherwise the rest of us have effed it up for everybody involved.
i think what you're missing is that ultimately these comments come from somewhere- even in jest. Although I'll probably subtract credibility of my argument by using a muppet show it makes a good point- there's a song on Avenue Q called "Everyone's a little bit racist" which has a line "ethnic jokes may be uncouth, but you laugh because it's based on truth."
ReplyDeleteWhen we say things that are racially insensitive it is because ultimately we believe that there lies truth (even if just a bit) behind what we say and thus our words speak more volumes then we may intend. What troubles me the most is that he's the director of graduate studies for the africana program which means he has studied at least ONCE about issues of racism and should know the history behind the term "black bitch" and know that no matter how acquainted two subjects might be that is beyond the line of appropriate. Let us not forget that he's a professor and that type of joking with a student is out of line.
i'm pretty sure that i said all of that already at least on some level
ReplyDeleteI feel like this is one of those situations where people have to make it clear that this sort of behavior is unacceptable (from anyone, not just faculty). It seems like school officials didn't do a good enough job of sending the message, so I think it's pretty appropriate for students/alumni to make it clear. I actually agree with you on the general uselessness of forums, but apparently they're college students' weapon-of-choice when it comes to showing concern about something. And really there isn't much to be constructively gained from the situation (except, I guess, to inform/remind people of why the phrase "black bitches" is grossly offensive & out of line). So I think the students are basically doing the right thing, as long as they don't turn it into "a negro bonfire" (which is a hilarious term btw).
ReplyDeleteWait wait... So what we are saying is that "black bitches" don't really exist?!?!?!
ReplyDeleteWoah... Mind is blown. lol
- the other negro child
I'm trying to think of a way to say what I have to say without you dismissing me lol. I agree with lil miss sunshine, and though you may have addressed those issues, you ultimately dismiss the severity of them in my opinion. Was it not the forum and growing of this issue that brought national awareness and dialogue? Is it not this "blowing out of proportion" that shows people that this type of behavior is inappropriate.
ReplyDeleteI am so sick of outbursts like these being dismissed with apologies. I also think it's problematic to limit the discussion of an issue because a victim is embarrassed. The victim shouldn't have to feel embarrassed.
If there isn't enough coming out of these forums/ discussions each time an outburst like this comes out, why don't we think of an alternative besides quiet, hushed apologies and stepping down, which also don't change the larger society. Since it's your school, might be a good time to start suggesting. :)
@jurnell cockhren ummm, im sorry, were these women behaving like "black bitches" when their adviser called them this? It's not a question about whether or not they exists. He used it as a general term, not to describe their behavior. So a better question should be, "are all women black bitches?"
ReplyDelete